Leasing a Car vs. Financing a Car:
a Beginner's Guide
by Christopher Burdick
Many of the customers that we work with here at AutoHeroes have no interest
in leasing an automobile for one of two reasons. First, they think that
it's a bad idea to lease, for whatever reason, or second, they do not
know the advantages of leasing.
If you fall into either of those categories, then read on!
Leasing is a terrific way of getting a new car, if you fit a certain
criteria. Typically, people who would benefit from leasing are those who
drive under 20k miles a year, and have a safe place to keep their car
(ie: not parking it on the street).
Let's say that a particular customer fits these criteria. What might
convince them to lease a car? Let's take a customer I am working with
right now. She is a 30 year old woman who got a great job out of business
school and is making a good amount of money now. Her old Honda Civic is
on its last legs, and it's time to find a replacement. She is looking
at a BMW 325ic, so we'll use that car for a comparison.
Let's look at how much money she would spend over three years if she
leased the car versus paid for the car through financing, versus paid
cash for the car.
The price that I have negotiated for her on her BMW is $34,405.00. The
residual value of the car (what the dealer figures the car will be worth
after 3 years) will be about $25,000) When all the taxes, etc. are added
in, she is looking at a monthly lease payment of about $407.00 over 3
years of ownership. Since leases generally run for 36 months, we'll say
that after the first lease ends, she'll get another new car with a lease
the same as the first.
Now, if she decides that she wants to make payments on the car, stretched
out over 5 years. Using the same sale price of the car, she is looking
at a monthly payment of $683.36, at 5% financing per year.
Now, here's a spreadsheet I made up that shows her costs over a period
of 60 months:
So let's make it easy and look at each option:
There are a few advantages to leasing. First, an individual who could
not afford to finance a certain car due to high monthly payments can lease
the same vehicle for a lower monthly payment. Second, by leasing a car,
you turn the vehicle in before the factory bumper-to-bumper warranty expires,
and therefore you never have to deal with mechanical difficulties. Also,
at the end of your lease, you can walk away from the car, and not have
to worry about negotiating its trade in value. At the end of 36 months,
you're done. The disadvantage of leasing is that in the long run, the
customer will spend more money than through financing or by paying cash.
If you don't like the idea of leasing because you want to own your car,
but you cannot afford to buy the car outright, then financing is the way
to go. Financing is the way most people decide to pay for their cars,
however it may not be the best way. The high monthly prices can make for
a problem at the end of the financing period. Some people find it hard
to pay upwards of $700.00 a month for a car, especially in that last year
of financing where the customer would be driving a 5 year old car, and
still be making those payments. Leasing sometimes looks really good in
Paying with cash makes the most sense on paper. By buying the car outright,
you avoid finance rates and the hassle of making monthly payments. However,
by keeping the car for a long period of time, you are virtually guaranteed
to take a hard hit when it comes time to trade the car in. If a customer
can afford to pay with cash, it makes the most financial sense if they
trade their automobiles in after every 3 or 4 years, before the value
of their car really depreciates.
When it comes time to make a decision as to which method of payment makes
the most sense for you, examine the benefits of each choice. The method
you choose should be dictated by what makes you feel the most comfortable
and which fits your needs best.
< Return to Articles main